Should Emmett have felt guilty for stealing someone else’s blind date?
Should he have made his pact with Lucy?
Could you forgive your significant other if you thought they were responsible for your child’s death?
Is anything truly unforgivable?
Was Lucy to blame for her parent’s divorce? For her brother’s death?
Which was worse … Emmett not telling Tatum the truth or Tatum not forgiving him?
Had Tatum not been responsible for Lucy’s accident, do you think she would have forgiven Emmett?
Have you ever done something that caused your child harm or could have caused them harm?

For Lucy

Book Club Questions